Saturday, January 22, 2022
HomeWorldHow Djokovic Spurred Debate on the Fairness of Border Policies

How Djokovic Spurred Debate on the Fairness of Border Policies


The Australia Letter is a weekly newsletter from our Australia bureau. Signal up to get it by e-mail.

A regular trickle of passers-by stopped in entrance of the Park Hotel in Melbourne on Saturday, pausing to take photographs, browse the chalk crafting scrawled on the developing — “free them all” and “30 small children locked inside listed here and tortured for 3,092 days” — or peer up, seeking to catch a glimpse of Novak Djokovic, the tennis star who experienced been detained inside of.

Camped throughout the road, planning to publish an post about how Mr. Djokovic’s situation had drawn notice to the plight of the refugees and asylum seekers held inside of, I caught snippets of their discussions.

“Did you know they’ve been in there for 9 several years?” one particular female exclaimed to her companion.”

“I by no means understood about this,” a male informed a single of the dozen refugee advocates who were protesting outside the hotel.

This would seem to be a frequent concept about the earlier week: shock domestically and overseas at the stringent ailments of Australia’s border control and detention technique, which Mr. Djokovic’s visa and vaccination saga has thrown into the spotlight.

This is the initially time that many of us have been exposed to the inner workings of a process where by you can be provided 20 minutes to describe why your visa should not be canceled, with limited authorized help, and to the wide vary of powers held by the immigration minister to cancel visas at his discretion — a power that has been termed “godlike” by some immigration specialists and even a previous immigration minister.

The way Mr. Djokovic was taken care of in the border regulate system was not unusual, explained Mary Anne Kenny, an associate regulation professor at Murdoch University, but “unlike a lot of other individuals who occur through that system, he was ready to get keep of a law firm and challenge it.”

The immigration minister’s extensive-ranging discretionary powers all around visas ended up originally intended to be made use of in circumstances in which a stringent and slim application of the regulation could possibly lead to unfair results, she said. For example, it could be utilised to grant visas to asylum seekers who did not technically tumble less than the definition of a refugee but had extenuating situations, this kind of as getting stateless.

But about time, she claimed, successive immigration ministers of all political stripes have increased the powers and utilized them for political finishes, specially in the earlier 20 yrs subsequent the introduction of Australia’s challenging-line border policy from asylum seekers arriving by sea.

“We most likely have some of the strictest border controls and detention regime of any place on the planet,” reported Abul Rizvi, a previous deputy secretary of the section of immigration.

But at the similar time, he extra, we’re a country of immigrants, with around 30 per cent of Australians born in a further nation — a significantly better percentage than other nations like the United States and Canada. “It’s an odd dichotomy,” he mentioned.

Australia relies on backpackers and Pacific islands laborers for substantially of our seasonal farm work force and temporary visa holders to fill careers in sectors like hospitality, construction and health care. But the state regularly will get criticism for its treatment of asylum seekers — beforehand positioning them on remote islands like Manus and Nauru, and now in detention hotels.

On Saturday, some observers outdoors the Park Resort, like Bobby Tomasevic, 55, have been considering about fairness — both of those for Mr. Djokovic and for the asylum seekers and refugees locked inside of.

“It provides you a sour sensation,” he reported. “It doesn’t have to be like this.”

Now for our stories of the 7 days.




Supply connection

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments